Monday, February 11, 2013

Google Docs vs. Microsoft Office

Hi Greg,

As per your request, I have compared Microsoft Office to Google Docs and provided a brief recap of the pros/cons as well as my final recommendation.  Since we are currently using Microsoft Office, you are already familiar with the features and benefits.  Google Drive has many of the same features only with added ease of use and increased accessibility.  A few main examples of where Google Drive can help us become more efficient are as follows:
·         File Sharing & Collaboration:  Rather than emailing large files back and forth to multiple people for editing, Google Docs provides a place for multiple people to revise docuements and tracks these revisions for others to see.  It also allows for real-time editing  allowing others to see what is being worked on at that exact moment in time. 
·         Accessibility: Currently, we must connect to our network in order to access the majority of our shared files.  As you know, we often have connectivity issues when traveling or working off-site preventing access to our network.  Google Docs prevents this situation and allows for you to access/edit documents anywhere you can connect to the internet.
·         Cost Effectiveness: Our licensing costs for Microsoft Office 2007 were close to $45,000 ($300 per person  x 150 employees).  Google Docs ranges anywhere from $5 to around $15  per person depending on which version we chose to utilize.  Assuming we want the most functional version, we are looking at a total cost of $2,250 which represents a savings of $42,750.
·         Training: Google offers free training via WebEx and online seminars. 

As with any business decision, there are pros and cons to transitioning to a new system.   While I listed free training as an advantage, it is important to remember that nothing is truly free.  Since we have been operating on Microsoft Office for years, there are many employees who know ONLY this system.  Their learning curve may be more significant and therefore take more time completing day to day tasks.   I believe that the cost of the man hours spent learning the new system will far exceed our savings of $42,750.
Another major disadvantage is the questionable securities risks.  In my opinion, the three departments which would most often utilize Google Docs for sharing and collaborating  are Finance, Marketing and Human Resources.  These are also our three departments with the most confidential information.  There is no way to put a price a price on a potential security lapse.
As a final note, over the past year we have invested millions of dollars to transition to SAP.  Our main reasoning for the SAP implementation was to get all subsidiaries on one GLOBAL system.  Because all of our local and international subsidiaries (plus our parent company in France) operate using Microsoft, I don’t believe switching to Google docs is beneficial in the long-run.  Yes, it will allow us to more effectively collaborate but only with those who also utilize Google Docs, and unless we initiated a global change it really does not help us much.  From a human resources standpoint, employees are just now feeling 100% adjusted to SAP and all of the changes that came along with it.  Asking them to learn another system after finally becoming comfortable with SAP is asking too much. 
Please let me know if you require further analysis or would like me to dive deeper into the Features & Benefits of Google Docs.
Megan Healey

No comments:

Post a Comment